The broader context for universities means that academic staff are expected to engage in a range of activities, including: research, education, enterprise, professional practice, knowledge exchange, consultancy, leadership, regulation, corporate governance, and administration. Hence the need for the Academic Career Conversations tool.
A doctoral study (Harding, 2012) highlighted that, although many staff developers in universities are skilled and experienced in developing leaders and professional and support staff, they often lack confidence or opportunities to engage with academic staff development, or deem it is out of scope for their role. For some it is because academics seem more focused on developing professionalism within their discipline and, as they lack experience in this area, staff developers also lack confidence to become involved. In some institutions academic staff development is only focused on learning and teaching quality and is located in a separate department.
However, the evidence has shown that there is a need for academic staff development beyond discipline or learning and teaching development.
Expectations of Academics
Academics are expected to deliver in a range of academic practice, including: education, research, enterprise, professional practice, administration, and leadership within a changing landscape for higher education. Government requirements, student and employer needs, regulatory frameworks, professional standards, and the economic global environment and other factors mean that universities and their academics need to sometimes change the focus of their attention and emphasise one or more of these areas of academic endeavour to fit with external needs and demands.
Emerging academics
There is no ‘one way’ into an academic role or career. Traditionally many have come through an academic education route, progressing from post-graduate studies to early career researcher. Modern universities with a growing focus on industry and the professions mean that institutions may be more focused on professional, rather than traditional academic subject areas, and therefore many academic staff have been recruited from a wider range of backgrounds.
Although the term ‘emerging academics’ was not a term widely recognised in the literature, the concerns of staff working in universities who need to develop broader portfolios of work that take account of a wide range of academic responsibilities have been more widely discussed. The hierarchical structures of universities mean that there is also a prescribed ‘career route’ to more senior responsibilities, such as professor or university leadership.
A definition of ‘emerging academics’ was coined by Harding (2012):
‘Emerging academic staff are those who were primarily teachers, or researchers, or who have joined HE from professional practice, who are now developing their own academic identity by developing their confidence and competence to engage in a rounded portfolio of academic activities including education, research, enterprise and professional practice. This engagement has the potential to yield benefits for the institution, the career of the individual academic, and the students who will ultimately benefit by learning from those who are themselves learning.’
In this research study it also became apparent that academics lack, or are keen for, or access development to support their careers. It does not matter what age or stage of career journey, or position in the hierarchy somebody is at, their career development needs are similar – as everyone is starting from somewhere with either the opportunity, or the aspiration (or both) to progress.
Academic Identity and Career – by Accident or Design?
The data showed us that often career development happens by accident, or is the result of circumstances, and less often the result of a proactive approach to planning a career.
Within this complex context individual academics are striving to develop their academic identity and careers, and yet find they have little time to reflect on, or to plan, their career journey. Similarly, the skills of line managers and staff developers are limited in supporting proactively the careers of other academics or careers.
There are several reasons for this. Reasons include lack of time or attention; when people have not been fully supported in their own careers and have not been socialised into effective ways of doing so, they sometimes find it difficult to support others.
Additionally, we heard many stories of how academic careers progress by accident rather than design; and support often depends on the good fortune of being surrounded by another, or others, who have the skills and capability and inclination to give time to nurture the careers of others.
Even professional staff developers are sometimes challenged by the idea of supporting academic careers. Although many staff developers are skilled and experienced in developing leaders and professional and support staff, they often lack confidence or opportunities to engage with academic staff development, or deem it is out of scope for their role.
For some it is because academics seem more focused on developing professionalism within their discipline and, as they lack experience in this area, staff developers also lack confidence to become involved. In some institutions academic staff development is only focused on learning and teaching quality, and sometimes research support, and is located in a separate department. Our research has demonstrated that there is a need for academic career support beyond discipline, or learning and teaching, or research development. Leadership development is not consistently offered across the sector, and even then it is often supported by external providers.
Participants said:
“Academics think that as they progress up the ladder that they need less and less continuing professional development (CPD) and actually the reverse is true.The more the academic processes up, the more CPD they need. That is true because they then start managing teams, they manage budgets, they manage difficult people….I wasn’t born with the ability to manage difficult conversations, so all of those are skills that become necessary as you progress up the career ladder.”
“Particularly when you get to professor you’ve got to be able to ask yourself, well what now? I think it is something around that ongoing engagement of how you can make what you do bigger than just yourself potentially.”
In this study we are not looking at the development of academic skills, but at developing the skills and practice for thinking about and planning for the evolution of a career – whether it is one’s own career, or for line managers, peers, coaches, mentors, and staff developers supporting the careers of others.
Academic Career Conversations © 2024 by Colleen Harding, Joan Reid, Sally Jackson & Sophie Lovejoy is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International licence.

